oursin: China hedgehog and the words It's always more complicated (always more complicated)

People on bluesky have been sending up the claim that GPT-5 boosts ChatGPT can provide PhD-level expertise.

After all, if you ask me for Mi Xpertise, you are likely to get 'it's complic8ed' and your ear bent with perhaps TMI on the subject, and what the areas of uncertainty are.

Do we not think that it would be more like having an overconfident mansplainer in one's pocket?

This led me to the teasing memory of a quotation, which I have tracked down and found has been researched in considerable depth here: Quote Origin: I Wish I Was As Sure of Any One Thing As He is of Everything.

It's fairly reliably attrib. to Lord Melbourne about the historian Thomas Macaulay (not, we fear, a member of the discipline given to declaring IAMC, sigh). Though it's been ascribed to various about various (funnily enough, all blokes) over the years.

oursin: The Delphic Sibyl from the Sistine Chapel (Delphic sibyl)

Article in the Guardian 'The Guide' section, which is not online (at least as yet) - it's in the series 'Solved! your crucial cultural questions answered', on the question 'Do uncertain times always result in great art?'

(Historian, remembering an undergraduate lecture during which lecturer on ye medeevles remarked that 'all ages were ages of change', deposeth that all times are probably uncertain for somebody and some sections of the populace, but wotevah.)

The article does point out that any Great Stuff that was produced during Some Period of Upheaval tends to be what goes down in the Annals of Memory and not necessarily the stuff that was, e.g. topping the charts.

As I have, my dearios, remarked on various occasions, what has lasting legs for posterity is not necessarily what is beloved in the immediate moment and the can't keep it on the shelves bestseller, just sayin'.

But I was also given to muse that, it does rather depend on what you mean by 'great art' and sometimes, what we now think of as lasting achievements of their day were the disposable popular entertainment to their contemporaries.

Thinking of uncertain times, such as, o, how about the 1930s? and what are lasting classic and beloved genres and works? the Hollywood musical, screwball comedy, the golden age mystery, the noir thriller in its written form (the movies were somewhat later), some of Noel Coward's most enduring plays. Delafield's Provincial Lady. Winifred Holtby's South Riding.

oursin: a hedgehog lying in the middle of cacti (Hedgehog among cacti)

I am coming around to a consideration that I am officially An Old and in a risk group, though only by reason of age and not for any concomitant reason of health, and therefore that international travel is probably not going to be the most sensible of ideas in the foreseeable future.

I note that An Institution with which I have some association has already put out a notice to its staff and people involved in its projects to eschew international events.

I further note that although Wiscon has so far said that it is going ahead (though may reconsider) I have not yet heard anything about the Academic Conference I was intending attending shortly afterwards, and I suspect that this is more about the ongoing situation than the organisers not having managed to get together the usual organisational details email in over a month since sending out acceptance of papers. Which suggests it may not be happening or is being postponed or turning into a virtual conference.

I have been holding off on making travel arrangements anyway until all this was a bit more settled.

It's rather irksome because the timing was such that it would have enabled me to fit in a side-trip to polish off some research, but, well, them's the breaks.

***

And in the realm of, other minor frets of life do not vanish (I refer my dr rdrz to the genre of novels about the Phoney War and the early part of the War once it had started not being Phoney), I am wondering whether I need to get a new phone, chiz, moan, whinge.

With the battery which lasts well under 24 hours on full charge (having lasted over 2 days when the thing was new), and the thing whereby every so often when it's charging it somehow doesn't realise it's supposed to be fast charging... Could Do Better.

*Thomas Nashe, In Time of Pestilence, 1593.

oursin: image of hedgehogs having sex (bonking hedgehogs)

Britons having less sex and digital life may be to blame – study

It's not actually stated in that article - maybe it is in the study - but I think what they are talking about when they are talking about 'having sex', is having some form of sexual activity with another person? Since it's phrased as 'sexual contact' we presume that they're not factoring in self-pleasuring? I think this should at least be explicit, because some of the benefits would probably still be there but others (the touching and cuddling and human contact side) would not.

I'm also, being a historian who is aware of how very recently people have even dared try quantifying this sort of thing and how great the pushback has been as to how significant the stats are and the querying of how much people lie and wondering how representative the samples are, and so on and on and on, wondering just how significant a fluctuation over 10 or so years is.

Because it's really, really - really, really, really - difficult to estimate how much people were doing the deed in or out of marriage in earlier times. And maybe there were fluctuations for all sorts of reasons - war, famine, pestilence, trade cycles, and other things I haven't thought of.

Except to make a guesstimate that there was probably a good deal of individual variation...

There is also a question to be asked about quantity vs quality.

oursin: The Delphic Sibyl from the Sistine Chapel (Delphic sibyl)

I've been thinking recently about the fact that, only a few years ago, I would now (or even somewhat earlier) be having talks with HR, winding down my work commitments, etc, because I would have reached Retirement Age.

Which is no longer a thing, and okay, I totally get that people of my years don't necessarily feel like being put out to grass just yet, though I can imagine instances where they wish they could.

It means I don't have a definite end-date to work to, and that I have all sorts of thinks about if/when I should depart the workplace. Sometimes I feel it would be nice if one were just told to stop. One could then think what next and make plans and so on.

I think this may be another of those cases where you find me and Robert Frost's Neighbour, sitting in the bar with our drinks and our backs turned to one another.

It resonates for me with that rather terrifying thing one hears about about people in certain sectors who claim that they have no work/leisure division, because work is So Much Fun and during what might be leisure they are checking their email, social media, etc for work-related matters.

Also with people who are being obliged, rather than spending their days looking for work, or engaging in relevant unpaid volunteering, having to do uncongenial labour for no pay, just for The Experience.

There is something there about necessary boundaries and their erosion that bothers me.

oursin: cartoon of cross hedgehog saying it's always more complicated (Complex hedgehog)
A very telling quotation by Edith Hamilton posted here by [livejournal.com profile] cdpoint:
Greater knowledge does not mean greater certainty. Oftenest the very reverse is true. We are certain in proportion as we do not know. We seem, indeed, so made that intellectual certainty is not good for us. We grow arrogant, intolerant, unable to learn and to attain better grounds of certainty precisely because we are certain.

Or, the more that we know, the more we know just how much we don't know.

May 2026

S M T W T F S
      1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31      

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated May. 31st, 2026 03:44 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios